Pesto grilled cheese sandwich with Italian bread, pesto, provolone, tomato, and American cheese. Crispy, melty, and ready in 15 minutes!
So, let’s set the scene. I’m sitting at this tiny, kinda run-down restaurant one rainy afternoon. You know the type — mismatched chairs, old posters on the wall. Zero expectations. I wasn’t really hungry-hungry, just snacky.
“Grilled cheese, sure, why not?” I thought. Safe bet, right?
Wrong. Well — right, but also so much more right than I ever imagined.
What arrived was not your average grilled cheese. No, this thing had pesto. Pesto on grilled cheese? Who knew? But wow. That first bite? It was like my brain did a double take. Creamy, herby, cheesy goodness all melted into perfectly crispy bread.
I literally sat there and thought, Oh, I’m stealing this idea.
So, naturally, the second I got home, I had to recreate it. Not tomorrow. Not next week. Right then. The result? This pesto grilled cheese sandwich recipe that I’ve now made so many times, I could probably whip it up blindfolded (but I won’t, because, y’know… hot pans).
And now? Plain grilled cheese just feels kinda… sad. You’ll see.
Why You’ll Love This Pesto Grilled Cheese Sandwich Recipe?
Alright, hear me out. Grilled cheese is already comfort food royalty. But this pesto grilled cheese sandwich? It’s like the cool cousin who studied abroad and came back with amazing stories and a much better wardrobe.
For starters — and I say this with love — regular grilled cheese can get boring fast. Bread. Cheese. Done. But when you add pesto? Oh, the game changes. Suddenly it’s fresh, herby, and way more interesting.
Then there’s the cheese combo. I use provolone and American. Why? Because life’s too short for just one cheese. Provolone melts like a dream and American adds that classic creamy pull. Plus, a little tomato in there keeps things juicy and stops it from being, well, too heavy.
Basically, this sandwich is cozy and exciting. How often can you say that?
Ingredient Notes:
Wanna know why this pesto grilled cheese sandwich works so well? Let’s break it down like we’re chatting in my kitchen.
-
Italian Bread: Not too flimsy, not too crusty. The Goldilocks of bread.
-
Butter: If you skip butter, we can’t be friends. Kidding. Kinda. Butter makes that golden crispy outside happen.
-
Pesto: Store-bought or homemade — no judgement. Either way, it brings all that garlicky, herby goodness to the table.
-
Provolone Cheese: Melts slow and smooth. Think of it as the laid-back cheese in the group.
-
Tomatoes: Fresh slices cut the richness. Plus they make it feel fancy, don’t they?
-
American Cheese: The OG. Brings creaminess and that nostalgic grilled cheese vibe.
How To Make Pesto Grilled Cheese Sandwich?
Step 1: Butter + Bread = True Love
Spread half your butter on one side of one slice of bread. That’s going face down in the skillet. Medium heat only — don’t crank it. Slow and steady wins the crispy race.
Step 2: Build the Layers of Deliciousness
On the unbuttered side, spread half your pesto. Then add provolone (melts like a champ), tomato slices (fancy), and American cheese (nostalgic). You’re stacking flavors here, people.
Step 3: The Top Slice Joins the Party
Spread the rest of your pesto on the second slice of bread and lay it pesto-side down on the sandwich. Butter the outside of that top slice. This is gonna crisp up too.
Want To Save This Recipe?
Step 4: Grill, Flip, and Wait (The Hardest Part)
Let the bottom brown gently — about 5 minutes. Flip carefully (channel your inner pancake flipper) and cook the other side till it’s golden and the cheese is melted and gooey. About another 5 minutes.
Step 5: Serve IMMEDIATELY
You think this sandwich is waiting for anyone? Nope. Slice it, plate it (or don’t, I eat mine straight from the pan half the time), and dive in.
Storage Options:
Look, this is best fresh. That said, stuff happens.
Pop leftovers in the fridge, wrapped tight. When ready, reheat in a skillet or toaster oven so the bread crisps back up. Avoid the microwave unless you’re okay with limp bread (I’m not).
Freezing? Eh… wouldn’t recommend. Grilled cheese just isn’t a freezer-friendly kind of dish.
Variations and Substitutions:
Honestly, you can play around a lot with this pesto grilled cheese sandwich. Here’s how:
-
Switch the cheese: Try mozzarella or Swiss if provolone isn’t your thing.
-
Add protein: Leftover chicken or crispy bacon? Yes, please.
-
Change up the bread: Sourdough or ciabatta makes it fancier.
-
Go plant-based: Vegan pesto + dairy-free cheese = easy swap.
This sandwich doesn’t mind a remix. It’s pretty chill like that.
What to Serve with Pesto Grilled Cheese Sandwich?
Could you eat it alone? Sure. Will you want sides? Oh yes.
-
Tomato Soup: Obvious, but perfect.
-
Salad: Adds freshness and makes you feel a little healthier.
-
Chips: Crunchy + melty = yes.
-
Pickles: Trust me. That salty snap works wonders here.
Frequently Asked Questions:
Can I use store-bought pesto?
Of course. Who’s judging? Store-bought works great.
What’s the secret to golden perfection?
Medium heat + patience. Rushing = burnt bread. Slow cooking = crispy magic.
Can I make this ahead of time?
I mean… technically yes. But grilled cheese is always better right off the skillet. Period.
And there it is — my forever favorite Pesto Grilled Cheese Sandwich. Simple, melty, crispy, and somehow comforting and a little fancy all at once.
So now I gotta ask… what’s your grilled cheese wildcard ingredient? Tell me — I’m always looking for excuses to try new twists!
<Remember it later>
Planning to try this recipe soon? Pin it for a quick find later!
<Remember it later>
Planning to try this recipe soon? Pin it for a quick find later!
Keep the Flavor Coming – Try These:
Pesto Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Ingredients
- 1 tablespoon softened butter divided
- 2 slices Italian bread
- 1 tablespoon prepared pesto sauce divided
- 1 slice provolone cheese
- 2 slices fresh tomato
- 1 slice American cheese
Instructions
Prepare the bread.
- Spread half of the softened butter evenly on one side of a slice of Italian bread. Place the buttered side face down onto a nonstick skillet set over medium heat.
Assemble the sandwich layers.
- Spread half of the prepared pesto sauce on the unbuttered side of the bread now in the skillet. On top of the pesto layer, arrange the slice of provolone cheese, followed by the tomato slices, and then the slice of American cheese.
Complete the sandwich.
- Spread the remaining pesto sauce onto one side of the second slice of bread. Position this slice pesto-side down over the stacked ingredients in the skillet. Butter the top side of the bread evenly.
Cook the sandwich.
- Allow the sandwich to cook gently for approximately 5 minutes, or until the underside becomes golden brown and crisp. Carefully flip the sandwich and continue to cook for an additional 5 minutes, or until the opposite side is equally golden and the cheese has melted thoroughly.
Serve.
- Once both sides are golden and crisp, remove the sandwich from the skillet. Slice and serve immediately while hot for the best texture and flavor.
Notes
I’m Bitty, owner of nodashofgluten.com, where I share simple, delicious recipes for all tastes, including gluten-free. Check out my “About Me” page for more info!
